User blog comment:SkittyTheTwit/New Object Show Idea!/@comment-5271031-20140715002916

OH PLEASE, NO.

The idea is very creative, of course, but just for one year? Doesn't really seem worth it, when these competitions usually last more than one year-- even two years or more. So although no one has super powers, it sorta... isn't going to work out. It's not even worth the competition. Only absolute suckers would have to fall for this and endure trouble for two years or longer and only withhold powers for one year.

And if you plan to animate it; don't. It's overdone. It's repetitive. And unless you can miraculously blow many out of the water, chances are it will be a big flop no one will care about or be uncomfortable watching. Hey, I've an idea! Why don't you write it instead? No, no, wait, seeing these descriptions, I honestly don't think you're cut out for a blog series. To be honest, if you're going to do something like this, I think it'll fit more in a comic perspective. Barely anyone does that! But it's probably just me. Do what you want, but if you're going for a fantasy perspective, please think about the most fitting format.

And what Meester Tweester said; beef up the personalities. It's more of a title than a personality. The bonus lets on more about them than their personality description, for crying out loud! It doesn't seem like a good object show if you leave it like this.

However improvement you require, I'm still very intrigued by this idea. If pulled off correctly, it'd be a unique twist to the fandom, and I'd very much would like to see this played out. If, of course, you were able to make it work better.